Building a sequence that generates consistent replies takes work. There’s no template that guarantees results and no AI that can do the thinking for you. These tools are useful as starting points, giving you ideas and structure to work from. But you will need to finetune them to match your specific market, your specific buyers, and your specific value proposition.
The reason is simple. Each industry is different and so is every buyer. A sequence that works for selling marketing software to agencies will fall flat when selling manufacturing equipment to plant managers. You have to adapt to your particular situation. The goal shouldn’t be to process 1,000 leads just to get two prospects. That signals extreme inefficiency. You’ll cycle through potential customers at an unsustainable rate, increasing costs and burning through leads that might have converted with a better approach.
In this post, we’ll assume your technical setup is solid so we can focus entirely on sequence configuration and the optimization process. See our post entitled: Keeping Your Outreach Emails Out of Spam
Understand your platform’s capabilities
Not all sequence platforms are created equal. The flexibility your platform offers will determine how effectively you can test, learn, and optimize. Before you start building, make sure you understand what’s available to you.
The most important capabilities to look for fall into a few categories.
For outreach channels, can the platform send from multiple email addresses? Can it send SMS? (Note that SMS legally requires recipient consent, or you may be subject to fines in the U.S. under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act or TCPA). Can it include call tasks and manual tasks like social outreach? Some industries respond better to certain channels. You need the ability to test different combinations.
For email functionality, does it support threading and quoting between steps? Will it skip holidays and weekends? Can it send from multiple mailboxes and emulate human sending patterns for better deliverability? These details affect whether your emails land in the inbox and feel personal when they arrive.
For tracking and compliance, does it allow tracked links? Does it support custom domain links? Can it deliver your multimedia content? Does it support UTM parameters for attribution? Can it deliver by recipient time zone? Does it automatically unenroll leads that bounce or unsubscribe? These features protect your reputation and give you the data you need to improve.
For analytics, does it provide detailed and accurate reporting so you can quickly identify what’s working? This is critical. Without reliable data, you’re guessing. See our post entitled: Are the Email Outreach Analytics You Are Relying On Accurate?
Do you need more than just email?
It depends on your industry and your buyers. Some industries rely heavily on SMS. Think about it. Have you received any SMS pitch messages lately? It’s common in certain verticals like, car sales, real estate, home services, and local B2B. (Note that SMS legally requires recipient consent, or you may be subject to fines in the U.S. under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act or TCPA).
Some businesses are not comfortable sending SMS for prospecting and prefer to stick with email only. Others combine email with social connection requests and phone calls. The right mix depends on where your prospects spend their attention and how they prefer to be contacted.
This is where testing comes into play. You won’t know what works best for your audience until you try multiple approaches and measure the results. Start with email as your foundation, then layer in additional channels one at a time so you can isolate what’s driving results.
One important note on LinkedIn. The LinkedIn User Agreement, Section 8.2.13, does not allow the automation of connection requests or the sending of automated messages. If you’re using a platform that automates this, you will eventually receive a warning and your account can be suspended or terminated. Manual social touches take more effort but keep you compliant and your account safe.
Structure your sequence thoughtfully
The structure of how your steps flow has a significant impact on results. A common mistake is treating every email as an isolated message rather than thinking about the sequence as a conversation that builds over time.
Anything over six email touches starts to feel excessive and may prompt spam complaints. This happens when a recipient marks your email as spam, which reports it to their mailbox provider. The two largest B2B email providers in the US are Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace. Get enough complaints with either and it will affect your deliverability to all of their customers. Soon you’ll find yourself living in the junk folder.
One approach that works well is organizing your sequence around message themes. Here’s an example structure:
Email 1 should be short. Introduce what you do and mention some recognizable clients you’ve served. Identify their problem, present your solution, and include a low pressure call to action like a link to a landing page where they can learn more.
Email 2 is a short follow up. The previous email is quoted below so the recipient has context without needing to search their inbox.
Email 3 is the qualifier. Ask if they’re the right person to contact for your purpose. This can prompt a response even if you’ve reached the wrong person, as they may redirect you to the correct contact.
Email 4 introduces a new theme with a new subject line. When configured, this starts a fresh thread without any previous messages quoted. Reintroduce what you do and your client references, but take a different angle. Address their problem and your solution from a new perspective.
Email 5 is another short follow up with Email 4 quoted below.
Email 6 is the breakup message. Acknowledge that your timing may be off since you haven’t received a response. Mention that you can reach out again in the future or invite them to contact you if anything changes. This soft close sometimes prompts replies from prospects who were interested but busy.
A/B testing your first step
Your first email is the most important message in your sequence. It determines whether the prospect engages or ignores everything that follows. This is a good place to test your subject and message.
A/B testing means running two variations of the same email to different portions of your list and measuring which performs better.
Start with subject lines. The subject line determines whether your email gets opened at all. Test different approaches. Direct versus curious. Short versus slightly longer. Question versus statement. Name of their company included versus not. Run each variation to at least 100 to 200 leads before drawing conclusions. Smaller sample sizes can mislead you.
Test your opening message line. This is the first thing the prospect reads after opening. Does a question perform better than a statement? Does leading with their pain point outperform leading with your credibility? Test and measure.
Then test your call to action. Does asking for a meeting outperform a softer ask like visiting a landing page? Does offering something of value like a helpful blog post, case study or short video increase replies?
The teams that consistently improve their results are the ones running these tests methodically. They don’t guess. They let the data tell them what works. Your platform should make it easy to split traffic between variations and report on performance by version. If it doesn’t, you’re flying blind.
Segment-based personalization
One of the biggest myths in outbound is that you need to deeply personalize every email for every prospect. The AI vendors love to promise this. Research each lead, reference something specific about them, make every message feel handcrafted. It sounds great in theory.
In practice, it doesn’t scale. Whether you’re sending five hundred or thousands of emails per month, you cannot spend 15 to 30 minutes researching each prospect and crafting a custom message. The math doesn’t work. You’d need a team of SDRs doing nothing but writing emails all day.
The exception is enterprise account based marketing where you’re targeting a small list of high value accounts. In that case, deep personalization makes sense because each deal is worth the investment. You might have 20 target accounts and each one justifies real research and custom messaging.
For everyone else, the practical approach is segment-based personalization. This means grouping your prospects by industry, company size, persona, or use case and creating tailored messaging for each segment.
Instead of one generic sequence, you might have a version for manufacturing, a version for healthcare, a version for financial services, and so on. Each version speaks to the specific pain points, language, and priorities of that vertical. The prospect reads it and feels like you understand their world.
You can take this further by segmenting within verticals. A sequence for manufacturing plant managers will read differently than one for manufacturing procurement directors. Same industry, different priorities, different messaging.
This approach gives you efficiency with enough relevance to drive engagement. It’s not one to one personalization, but it’s far more effective than blasting the same generic message to everyone. Smart segmentation works, especially when combined with continuous testing.
Timing and cadence matter
How many days should you wait between touches? There’s no universal answer, but here’s what tends to work.
For most B2B outreach, spacing emails 3 to 5 business days apart strikes a balance between staying top of mind and not being annoying. Shorter gaps can feel aggressive. Longer gaps risk losing momentum and being forgotten.
Some teams see better results with tighter cadence in the first few touches, then spacing out toward the end. For example, Email 1 on day one, Email 2 on day 4, Email 3 on day 8, then longer gaps of 7 to 10 days for the remaining touches.
Industry matters here too. If you’re selling to fast moving startups, quicker cadence may work. If you’re selling to enterprise buyers who move slowly, give them more breathing room. Test different timing and let the data guide you.
Variables to consider adding
There are several elements you can incorporate to increase engagement.
A book a meeting link gives interested prospects an easy next step. Keep it low pressure. Some people prefer to schedule on their own terms rather than going back and forth over email.
Include a link to something valuable like a blog post addressing a core problem in their industry. Make sure it’s genuinely helpful and not a sales pitch disguised as content. Value builds trust. See our post entitled: Using Gated Content to Capture Leads
If you’re selling something that has a short video demo and your email outreach platform supports multimedia, that’s another low pressure option. Let the prospect see what you offer without committing to a call.
Link best practices
Links you include should use custom domains. This means your sequence platform will rewrite any link to match the domain in your sending email address. This consistency helps with inbox deliverability. Even your unsubscribe link should match. See our post entitled: Protect Your Brand: Use a Separate Outreach Domain
Try not to include more than one link per email, a maximum of two. Too many links can trigger the recipient’s security systems and hurt your chances of reaching the inbox. Keep it simple.
Protect your reputation automatically
Your sequence should automatically remove bounces and unsubscribes. Bounces need to be removed so they don’t hurt your sender reputation by continuing down the sequence. Unsubscribes need to be honored to stay compliant with the CAN-SPAM Act, which requires you to stop emailing contacts who opt out and include your physical address at the bottom of each email.
If your platform doesn’t handle this automatically, you’re putting your deliverability at risk every time you send.
You can’t optimize without accurate analytics
If your analytics aren’t accurate, you’re optimizing blind. Here’s what to track and what the numbers should look like.
Open rates of 20% or higher are a reasonable target for cold email outreach. If you’re below that consistently, something is wrong with your tech setup, subject lines, your sender reputation, or your list quality.
Reply rates vary by industry. Highly competitive or saturated industries typically see 0 to 1%. Lower engagement industries fall in the 1 to 3% range. Highly engaged industries with solid targeting can achieve 5% or more. Know your benchmarks and measure against them.
One warning about inflated metrics. Many larger corporations use link scanners to protect themselves from malicious emails. These scanners automatically click every link in incoming messages to test for threats, which artificially inflates your open and click rates. Make sure your platform can filter out this bot activity so you’re making decisions based on real human engagement. See our post entitled: Are the Email Outreach Analytics You Are Relying On Accurate?
When to iterate versus when to kill a sequence
Not every sequence can be saved. Sometimes the targeting is wrong. Sometimes the offer doesn’t resonate. Sometimes you’re reaching the right people at the wrong time.
If you’ve run a sequence through a few hundred leads and you’re seeing open rates below 10% with near zero replies, something fundamental is broken. Tweaking subject lines won’t fix it. You need to check your tech setup, reputation, revisit your list, your targeting, or your core message.
If you’re seeing decent open rates but low replies, the issue is likely your messaging or your offer. Test different angles, different value propositions, or different calls to action.
If you’re seeing engagement early in the sequence but it drops off sharply, your follow ups may be too aggressive or too repetitive. Adjust the cadence or change the theme in later touches.
Optimization means making informed changes based on data. But it also means knowing when to stop investing in something that isn’t working and start fresh with a new approach.
0 Comments