The basics: what is a domain?
A domain is the web address people type into their browser to find your website, for example yourcompany.com. When you create email addresses like name@yourcompany.com, you’re using that same domain to send and receive emails. Your domain is your digital identity. It’s how customers find you, how partners reach you, and how your business communicates with the world.
With that foundation in place, let’s get to it.
Your primary domain is too valuable to risk
Even with a perfect technical setup, many things can damage your domain’s reputation. Excessive email outreach volume, too many spam complaints, high bounce rates, spoofing attacks, spam sounding content. Any of these can trigger email providers to downgrade your sender reputation. Once that happens, your emails start landing in spam instead of the inbox. And the damage isn’t limited to your outreach campaigns.
Think about how you use your primary business email every day. You communicate with team members, existing customers, potential customers, contractors, vendors, and partners. You send quotes, invoices, contracts, and project updates. This channel of communication is essential to your business operations. It cannot be disrupted without serious consequences.
Now imagine if most of those emails suddenly started landing in spam. Your invoices don’t get paid because clients never saw them. Your proposals go unanswered because they’re buried in junk folders. You could miss customer orders. Your team misses critical updates because internal emails aren’t being delivered. You’d be left wondering why no one’s responding, burning time on follow-up calls, and trying to figure out what went wrong.
This scenario isn’t hypothetical. It happens to companies that use their primary domain for cold outreach and suffer reputation damage as a result. The fallout extends far beyond missed sales opportunities. It disrupts core business operations and it can take a long time to fix and recover. That’s a problem you can’t afford. See our post entitled: Are the Email Outreach Analytics You Are Relying On Accurate?
Growth requires outreach, and outreach carries risk
Here’s the tension. To grow your business, you need to reach new prospects. You need to target specific decision makers in industries where your ideal customers operate. There are thousands of potential buyers out there who could benefit from your product or service. The challenge is reaching them at sufficient volume to build a meaningful pipeline.
Cold outreach is one of the most effective ways to do this. But cold outreach, by its nature, carries deliverability risk. You’re emailing people who didn’t ask to hear from you. Some will mark you as spam. Some email addresses will bounce. Some recipients will never engage. Over time, these signals accumulate and can hurt your sender reputation.
The solution is simple. Don’t put your primary domain at risk. Use separate domains dedicated to outreach.
How to choose your outreach domains
The best approach is to purchase additional domains that align with your brand but are distinct from your primary domain. This protects your main business communications while giving you dedicated infrastructure for prospecting.
Here are three examples of how to structure outreach domains:
yourcompanyhq.com
tryyourcompany.com
demoyourcompany.com
These variations clearly connect to your brand, so prospects can still recognize you, but they’re isolated from your primary domain. If one of them suffers reputation damage, your core business email remains unaffected.
What TLD should you use?
TLD stands for Top Level Domain. It’s the extension at the end of your web address. Examples include .com, .net, .org, .io, and many others.
With so many options available, which should you choose? Stick with the most established TLDs. Email providers have more historical data on these extensions, and they’re generally viewed as more trustworthy. Every small detail matters when you’re trying to land in the inbox instead of spam.
The most reliable TLDs for outreach are .com, .net, .co, .io, .ai, and .org.
Avoid obscure or trendy TLDs that email providers may view with suspicion. The goal is legitimacy, and established TLDs help you achieve that.
The 30 day waiting period
You’ve purchased your new domains. Ready to start sending? Not so fast.
This step is critical and often overlooked. Blacklist monitoring services track new domain registrations. Many will automatically blacklist newly purchased domains for approximately 30 days. This is a spam prevention measure. Bad actors frequently register new domains for malicious purposes, so fresh domains are treated with suspicion by default. Note that it may take 24 hours for new domains to appear in these blacklists and this is when the 30 day count begins.
If you start sending emails from a brand new domain before this blacklist period expires, you risk damaging your reputation before you’ve even begun. Your emails will be flagged, your deliverability will suffer, and you’ll be starting from a deficit instead of a clean slate.
Wait the 30 days. Use this time to complete your set up. Configure your domain’s DNS records, build your landing page, and prepare your sequences in your email outreach platform. Patience here pays dividends later. If your email outreach platform does not have a feature to test your settings, you can use MXToolbox. You can also test the status of your domain in the Spam Eating Monkey blacklist. They almost always blacklist new domains.
Warming up your domains properly
Thirty days have passed. Your domains are off the blacklists. Now you’re ready to send, but not at full volume.
If you suddenly send 500 emails from a brand-new domain in a single day, email service providers will flag you as a spammer almost immediately. Your messages will go straight to junk folders, and all of your preparation will be wasted. A “blast” happens when an unsophisticated email platform sends hundreds of messages at once instead of spacing them out naturally. To email providers, that behavior is a clear red flag and a strong signal that the sender cannot be trusted.
Warming up a domain means gradually increasing your sending volume over time. This builds a positive sender reputation by demonstrating consistent, legitimate email behavior. Here are the best practices.
Limit email addresses per domain. Use no more than two email addresses per outreach domain. This keeps your sending patterns small, manageable, and reduces risk.
Cap daily sending volume. Send no more than 50 emails per day per domain. Consider sequenced follow ups. That translates to roughly 25 emails per email address. This may feel small, but it’s the pace that protects your deliverability.
Scale up gradually. Don’t start at 50 emails per day. Begin with 3 to 5 and increase steadily over the course of a month until you reach your 50 target volume per domain. This gradual ramp up signals to email providers that you’re a legitimate sender, not a spammer.
Use a platform that supports multiple mailboxes per user. If you need higher volume, and most sales teams do, you’ll need multiple domains and mailboxes working in parallel. Make sure your email platform can handle this without creating management headaches.
See our post entitled: Keeping Your Outreach Emails Out of Spam
The spray and pray trap
There’s an old saying in email outreach called spray and pray. The idea is that you need to send massive volumes of emails to generate a handful of replies. It’s a numbers game, the thinking goes. More emails equals more chances. Why Simple is Better in Digital Marketing
This approach is based on a flawed assumption. Yes, you’ll need volume if your technical setup is broken and most of your emails are landing in spam. When only a fraction of your messages reach the inbox, brute force feels like the only option.
But if your technical foundation is solid, if your DNS records are configured correctly, your domains are warmed properly, and your platform is functioning as it should, then volume becomes less important than quality. When your emails actually reach the inbox, results come down to three things.
First, your messaging. Is it relevant, clear, and compelling? Does it speak to your prospect’s specific pain points? See our post entitled: AI vs. Manual Outreach: What Works Best for B2B Sales?
Second, your offering. Does your product or service deliver real value? Is there genuine demand for what you’re selling?
Third, your credibility. Can you demonstrate results with existing customers? Do you have case studies, testimonials, or recognizable logos that build trust?
When deliverability is handled, these factors determine your success, not raw email volume. You can send fewer emails and get better results because more of them are landing where they should and saying something worth reading.
The takeaway
Your primary domain is critical infrastructure. It powers your day to day business communications, and disrupting it has consequences that extend far beyond sales. Don’t put it at risk with cold outreach.
Instead, invest in dedicated outreach domains. Choose brand aligned variations with established TLDs. Wait out the blacklist period. Warm them up properly. Follow sending limits and best practices.
Once you’ve checked these boxes, you can focus on what actually drives results. Refining your messaging, sharpening your value proposition, and building credibility through customer success. Technical discipline gives you the foundation. Strategy and execution build the pipeline.
See our post entitled: Are the Email Outreach Analytics You Are Relying On Accurate?
Protect your brand first. Then you can grow it.
0 Comments